Sunday, January 18, 2015

ON TO OSCAR.

The nominations are out, and spurred by some vestigial urge from my showbiz days I'm working on seeing the big ones and reporting back here whenever I get a chance.

The Grand Budapest Hotel. Wes Anderson heroes don’t usually have life-or-death crises; they suffer from misunderstandings. Some of these misunderstandings are large and threaten their happiness, but they’re nothing that can’t be straightened out, for in the Anderson universe good will and reasonableness are always popping out from around a corner, ready to set things right. Even criminals don’t give Anderson heroes much trouble. (The pirates in The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou were less of a threat than the Pirates of Penzance.) His movies have been like children’s-edition versions of Dickens, which is a large part of their pleasure, and also their limitation — they have a great range of amusing characters and incidents, but the viewer is always aware that this is not quite the world.

The Mitteleuropan fantasyland of Zubrowka, in which The Grand Budapest Hotel takes place, is not quite the world either — the visuals are rich as frosting; you can see how much pleasure Anderson gets from the very idea of an early-20th-Century alpine funicular. There is also the very Andersonian mentor-pupil relationship of Monsieur Gustave, the Hotel’s brilliant concierge whose aplomb, we come to realize, is not only inventive and industrious but magnificent and brave, and Zero the Lobby Boy, who climbs but is not a mere climber, which Gustave recognizes by instinct and seeks to encourage. And around many corners come many helpful people to lend Gustave and Zero support — most memorably the secret order of concierges known as the Society of the Crossed Keys.

But these helpers can’t do everything. There is a probate matter that has the appearance of a misunderstanding, and Deputy Kovacs attempts to deal with it as such; he is (spoiler) murdered for this misapprehension. His assassins, and Gustave’s and Zero’s main nemeses, are Dmitri and his enforcer Jopling, two genuinely savage creatures beyond the reach of all sentiment or reason, whose evil industry seems a match at least for the energy and good faith of our heroes. Also, from near the beginning of the film a great war threatens, and in the end it does more than that.

The Grand Budapest Hotel has all the pleasures we’ve come to expect from Anderson. The amplified grandeur of the Lubitsch-y, cinema buffa settings make it even easier than usual to expect them. But Lubitsch for all his kitsch was pretty wised-up, and I think Anderson is getting to be, too. Much has been made of the film’s inspiration by Stefan Zweig, not least by Anderson himself. I take him at his word: The melancholy for a vanished world — a world, as Zero, seen in his old age in the framing device, tells “the Author” was probably vanished even before the story began, but embodied and upheld by Monsieur Gustave — feels genuine, and informed by the sadder lessons of history and life. It’s not that kindness and its effects have left the world; just that their value has to be treasured and transmitted, maybe in movies like this.

That framing device makes the point beautifully. We see the message passed by elderly Zero to the Author, and the Author passing it on, through literature (and through difficulties which are only suggested but which to anyone who lived in the 20th Century will be perfectly clear) to his people. The evil in this world, this seems to say, does not refute the rosy Anderson idea of life; rather, vice-versa. Our problems, that is, may not all be misunderstandings, but when we insist on understanding we can yet triumph.

18 comments:

  1. The Mitteleuropan fantasyland of Zubrowka

    I haven't seen the movie, but Żubrówka is my favorite vodka- my friends' dad, a professor of Slavic languages, got us all hooked on it, then informed us that it wasn't available in the 'States, trace amounts of coumarin (not enough to make a healthy drinker bleed out, but probably enough to prevent strokes) caused the government to ban sales of it as a controlled substance.

    Every time I went to Europe, I'd buy a bottle of the stuff and a bottle of a local booze (genever, grappa, or the like). Thankfully, the government relented, and it is now readily available in a well-stocked liquor store.

    That is all, I got nothing else for this thread...

    ReplyDelete
  2. I absolutely loved this movie. To me, it was like being read a story by some old favorite uncle. Utterly delightful!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm sorry...is that a "thumbs up" or "thumbs down?" Too many words.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ubu Imperator10:59 PM

    Goddamn, Roy. I don't know why you're wasting your time with us rather than taking your proper place as an arts critic somewhere that you'd actually get paid, but we're luckier for it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. parsec12:49 AM

    It sounds like a lot of fun. There's definitely a place for that.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Rand Careaga1:32 AM

    If you thought that was too many words, Brad DeLong had some interesting thoughts, expressed in a longer read, on the film last spring. Anyway, it's a "thumbs up."

    ReplyDelete
  7. John Wesley Hardin1:33 AM

    Definitely one of the best movies of the year, and my favorite Wes Anderson movie now. Thanks for the lovely write-up, Roy. What you said.

    ReplyDelete
  8. JennOfArk1:37 AM

    Was going to watch it this evening on HBO, but missed the first 15 minutes and hate coming in late to a movie. Fortunately it's HBO so it will show at least 25 times over the next week; hopefully I'll make it to the couch to catch the beginning since you've reinforced my desire to watch.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Dude, you have to stop bringing out the pro chops, you make the rest of us hacks feel bad and raise the fucking bar pretty high while doing so.

    Seriously though, that is probably the most elegantly written, beautiful piece of prose I have read this year.

    Bravo Roy.
    ...

    ReplyDelete
  10. petesh9:38 AM

    It's beautiful, it's nuts, it's deep, and it has Ralph Fiennes being wonderfully silly. Did I mention it's gorgeous?

    ReplyDelete
  11. danfromny9:39 AM

    And it was funny. You forgot to mention that it was funny. Slapstick in the best of the tradition. Ralph Fiennes, not someone you would expect to be funny, had some great line readings and physical reactions.

    ReplyDelete
  12. timb11711:18 AM

    This. Who knew the sadist from Schindler's List could also play the opposite?

    Great movie and great performance

    ReplyDelete
  13. Brian Schlosser8:17 PM

    I've only been disappointed by Anderson once (The Darjeeling Limited), and delighted every other time. GBH is no different. At the risk of sounding all film-crity, it's his most mature work. I am behind it 100% at the Oscars.

    I also can't imagine what he'll be making when he's in his 50's...

    ReplyDelete
  14. Henry Holland12:06 AM

    I saw it today, really liked it a lot. Ralph Fiennes is fantastic, as is Tony Revolori as Young Zero. The large supporting is excellent as is the direction, cinematography and music. My only niggle is that there's that Anderson staple, the wink-wink nudge-nudge "Aren't we being so clever" gloss, but for me, it's a given in his movies.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Linnaeus12:09 AM

    Yeah, this was a pretty good one. Both the movie and Roy's writeup about it.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Kurzleg3:37 PM

    Me too! With this and Moonrise Kingdom, I think we're seeing Anderson transition into weightier subject matter but without losing the whimsical tone and style for which he's famous. I'll admit that I wasn't blown away on first viewing, but I chalk that up to seeing it in a refurbished theater that hadn't seemed to have worked out the kinks in its sound system. Having watched it about 15 times since then, it's been a pleasure each and every time.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Kurzleg3:41 PM

    Definitely his most mature. As I mentioned above, I think Moonrise Kingdom marked the beginning of a transition for Anderson. GBH continues it, and we can only hope it's not the apex.

    ReplyDelete