Tuesday, March 12, 2013

LOOKING IN ON OLD FRIENDS.

We've had a lot of fun with Mark "Gavreau" Judge here in recent weeks, so on a whim I dropped by the rightwing culture mag that employs him to see how he was passing his days. Behold:
Can the Hollywood reboot of The Fantastic Four, now in the works, succeed where the original movies failed? It all depends on whether producer Matthew Vaughn and director Josh Trank have the guts to do one thing: To make The Fantastic Four about the family versus communism.
Don't ever change, fella.

102 comments:

  1. So that none of you have to read it, here's the root of Judge's argument: Dr. Doom ruled a Soviet breakaway republic, therefore COMMIE. He then proceeds to complain that the movie didn't have COMMIES in it. I was going to refute this here, but one of the two commenters beat me to it:

    They had to revamp him, as the old Doom was something that no longer
    existed. That idea of the despot leader of a feudal Eastern European
    satellite country of communism is dated, and Doom was always at risk of
    descending into parody.


    So Acculturated seems to be on the verge of becoming self-refuting. I don't see why I shouldn't kick back with some lemon cookies and a glass of Knob Creek and just watch the explosion.

    ReplyDelete
  2. For fuck's sake, Latveria was not a communist country! it was an absolute monarchy! And Doom was its ruler. The comics make this explicitly clear. There is no party, no legislature, just the will of Doom.

    So much fail in one post.

    ReplyDelete
  3. "Family versus communism".

    Yes, because of course certain political ideologies make you infertile... wait huh?

    ReplyDelete
  4. If the guy must have a Communist villain for the FF, maybe we could work in the Red Ghost and his Super-Apes. Everything's better with monkeys, I'm told.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Spaghetti Lee11:03 PM

    Quick quiz: Is the demographic that spends the most money on summer action movies a) obsessed with communism, or b) too young to remember it? Take your time.


    For once, I'd like to see a 'rational capitalist' that's actually rational about capitalism.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It's pretty sad when someone can't even get the simplest form of propaganda right.

    ReplyDelete
  7. EndOfTheWorld11:05 PM

    I wonder if Mark ever saw the origin story of the Fantastic Four. In it, Reed Richards is so dang eager to beat the commies into space that he goads his friends onto an untested rocket ship. When Ben Grimm objects due to the reasonable safety concerns of flying a rocket through space, Sue calls him a coward and questions his commitment to "beating the commies."


    They go ahead with the test flight and, wouldn't you know, cosmic radiation turns them into a superpowered freakshow. Gosh, it's almost like there's a lesson there about the dangers of letting jingoism get ahead of reason. Nah, coudln't be.

    ReplyDelete
  8. So would I. But then he would cease to be capitalist. At least in the american sense.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think Mark only saw the stupid cartoon show with flaming asshat replaced by a robot.

    ReplyDelete
  10. It really is. I mean, the whole premise was strained and confused in the first place. But this is real "was it over when the Germans invaded Pearl Harbor?" kind of wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Yeah, it's not just about being wrong. It's being wrong about the wrong thing. It's fuckin' category error.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Halloween_Jack11:33 PM

    Now I know a little of how Paul Krugman must feel when he's facing someone in a "debate who's just making shit up, and not even faking it very well. As others have pointed out, the FF did in fact originally go up in space, and inadvertently got their powers, as part of the space race, and you later had the Red Ghost and his cosmic-powered monkeys (great band name); hell, you could even say that the Skrulls, with their shape-shifting powers and ability to infiltrate and sabotage without being caught, were a symbolic stand-in for the Red Scare. And, of course, almost all of Iron Man's foes in the early days were commies, even including the Black Widow (who fought him largely through her American dupe, a carnival archery trick-shot specialist nicknamed Hawkeye).

    But Doom was just a straight-up totalitarian, Big Brother in an iron corset, of the type that had been in power in different places around Eastern Europe well before the Russian Revolution (and have come back in different places after the dissolution of the USSR); he never bothered to justify his rule under any ideology, but just delivered two parts police state (mainly via robots) to one part straight-up personality cult. Lee and Kirby certainly weren't afraid to fall back on the Red Scare for their villains (not to mention the Yellow Peril, in the form of the Yellow Claw and the Mandarin), but they were onto something a little more subtle with Doom and Magneto, who were both victims of ethnic oppression who eventually became more oppressive than their original persecutors (well, maybe not Magneto, who never pulled off anything on the scale of the Nazis). This point has been made many times in the half-century or so of Marvel Comics' existence, and not always very subtly, either.

    And, yes, movie Doom is kind of dumb, but there are a lot of things about the FF movies that could be improved upon. (Literally, the only thing I want them to keep from the movies is Michael Chiklis as the Thing.) In particular, having the real Doom bring the resources of an entire nation against four civilians as retaliation for an old grudge could be pretty awesome, as well as have a certain historical resonance. Just please don't let someone like Mr. White People Don't Steal Bicycles get their hands anywhere near it.

    ReplyDelete
  13. montag211:37 PM

    "... family versus communism."

    There are so many things wrong with this that I don't have the patience to delineate them all.

    But, I'm pretty sure that Judge's idea of family is wrapped up in "Terry and the Pirates" and "Blackhawks."

    ReplyDelete
  14. wileywitch12:03 AM

    Family of what?

    ReplyDelete
  15. It's a good thing rightbloggers are so bad at pop culture, because they literally don't understand the difference between entertainment and propaganda, and/or they don't agree that there should be a distinction between entertainment and propaganda. (Arguably, this may itself be a large part of the reason that they're so bad at pop culture.)

    Frankly, most superhero movies already seem to me to have a fairly conservative premise, but since I'm not obsessed with the political propaganda value of every fucking movie I watch, that doesn't stop me from enjoying them.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Commies don't have families.


    They're grown on collective farms.

    ReplyDelete
  17. And of course, we're never going to have a successful film based on the Hulk comics until we accept that Bruce Banner is a huge green metaphor for privatizing the Post Office.

    ReplyDelete
  18. XeckyGilchrist12:17 AM

    Fine gravel, and then they let their pet cat shit in his shit!

    ReplyDelete
  19. I'm a suburban/city kid and my granpdarents where too... Oh, no! Commies everwhere and everywhgen!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Better a pet cat than that muthafuckin' robot.

    ReplyDelete
  21. sharculese12:34 AM

    You're thinking of the definition of success that involves 'being well received by the public and making money'. Judge is talking about the definition of success that involves 'being included in john nolte columns about movies that are secretly conservative'.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Fats Durston1:00 AM

    Well, there is the matter of Red Dawn (2: Hysteric Kim Jong-U(n)) in the theaters. I am afraid to look at its Box Office.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Fats Durston1:01 AM

    Dang, getting wistful about CoH...

    ReplyDelete
  24. MyPetGloat1:02 AM

    Someone needs to let Judge know guts and stupidity aren't the same thing.

    ReplyDelete
  25. AGoodQuestion1:10 AM

    Doom is a megalomaniac absolutist ruler who's convinced what's good for him is also the best for his country. If he's a communist, most of the hereditary rulers in history have been commies as well.


    I mean, it's just really a stretch. Marvel did create communist villains in the sixties. There's the roughly contemporary Fantastic Four baddie the Red Ghost, who's a genuine soviet superpatriot. He'd fit Judge's template much better, but for the fact that only comic book geeks would know who he was talking about.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Fats Durston1:11 AM

    Alternate history: Judge is in the writers' room of the Simpsons when they're composing the episode where Krusty has lost the rights to "Itchy and Scratchy" and someone says, "Hey, let's substitute an Eastern European cartoon 'Worker and Parasite' in his show." Judge: "Wait, guys, it's not funny unless it's 'Factory Owner and Parasite'."

    ReplyDelete
  27. I recently reread the first two Essential Iron Man collections and Kruschev is a recurring villain in the series, portrayed as a buffoon with steam practically coming out of his ears that Iron Man has gotten the better of his agents AGAIN. And the Black Widow's heart is melted by Hawkeye's concern for her, even though she's just using him.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Peter Milligan wrote a hilarious X-Men story where the REd Ghost was talking about restoring the Soviet empire and he would cut back to the apes, rolling their eyes and thinking "Oh joy, father's talking about THAT again..."

    I high recommend Milligan's 2007 series the Programme from DC, about lost Soviet Superhumans being unleashed on the modern day United states. Not as good as The Winter Men, about a similar subject, but pretty damn hilarious.

    ReplyDelete
  29. hells littlest angel1:49 AM

    Lava when he's been out drinking the night before. Diamonds when he's constipated.

    ReplyDelete
  30. I should have guessed, when Reed Richards devised a five-year plan! Johnny Storm was Flaming Red! Sue Storm Richards was the perfect invisible mole in the Pentagon McCarthy warned us about! (Mole Man was a diversion to throw us off.) Ben Grimm was as hard and stony as Stalinist ideology – only a blind woman would fall for his act! And back to "Dr." Richards, a typical unreliable liberal egghead – stretching and stretching the truth and twisting himself into knots, all to accommodate Communism!

    ReplyDelete
  31. For fuck's sake, Latveria was not a communist country! it was an absolute monarchy! And Doom was its ruler. The comics make this explicitly clear. There is no party, no legislature, just the will of Doom.

    Yes, and one of the better old series (John Byrne era) showed the Fantastic Four shocked that Doom's people liked him so much. He was a super-villain, but did pretty well by the peasantry and gypsies/Roma – at least by the time the series had moved beyond fun pulp and tried to add a little more moral complexity and character depth. (All relative, but still.)

    I got out of the boat, and sadly, this is Kulturekampf yet again – Judge really wants to see a film that's little more than triumphalism over Communism. It's like porn for the Saint Ronnie Evangelist set. And jeez, how boring. It doesn't matter that the Soviet Union disbanded in 1991 – in the heart of hearts, they long for Red Dawn on continuous loop, so they can relive their fear and chickenhawk bravado.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Well, remember when during his Senate confirmation process, John Roberts named Doctor Zhivago as one of his favorite movies? (North by Northwest was another.) Several of the Fox idiots on a panel expressed concern and called the film "a little bit commie," because, you know, RUSSIA, never mind the depictions of the communists in the film or Pasternak's horrible treatment at their hands in real life.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Does anyone know what the phrase "family versus communism" even means?

    ReplyDelete
  34. OK, I'm not the only one baffled by this phrase...

    ReplyDelete
  35. I could also see him genuinely liking Poochy.

    ReplyDelete
  36. satch7:44 AM

    In Sue's defense, she comes from a milieu where radiation and toxic waste, instead of killing you, gives you super powers. Y'know, I liked Gavreau's piece so much I'd like to buy him a drink. Hey, Bartender... another double benzene for Judge, and see what the rest of the boys from Acculturated will have!

    ReplyDelete
  37. fraser7:45 AM

    What puzzles me is the way they only refer to him as "Comrade K" in Iron Man. As if it was like the pre-Pearl Harbor comic books where they have obvious Hitler analogues but name them as "Toranian" or something.

    ReplyDelete
  38. fraser7:46 AM

    Of course, Doom battled Hell to save his mother's soul, so it's not as if he doesn't have family feeling himself.

    ReplyDelete
  39. I'll just leave this here -

    http://dangerousminds.net/comments/communisms_mightiest_super_heroes_what_if_stan_lee_and_jack_kirby

    ReplyDelete
  40. BigHank538:11 AM

    44 million domestic box office; official budget was 65 million. No need to fear that turkey coming back from the dead.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Derelict8:14 AM

    Okay, now I have some, well, I guess pity for the poor bastard. Life has to really, really suck when your expectation of entertainment is to receive a political lecture.

    ReplyDelete
  42. satch8:16 AM

    Of course, the upcoming "Olympus Has Fallen" demonstrates that those pesky North Koreans just never give up.

    ReplyDelete
  43. BigHank538:20 AM

    ...speaking of which, at the end of the first FF movie, how did the Human Torch leave that giant "4" burning in the sky?

    ReplyDelete
  44. fraser8:24 AM

    One obvious problem with Judge's script idea is that the FBI didn't actually try to shake Doom's control of Latveria--they let him be, even though he repeatedly tried to kill them. That makes them appeasers or terrorist-lovers or something, doesn't it?

    ReplyDelete
  45. fraser8:26 AM

    Or there's the Hulk crossover where his sidekick Rick Jones discovers an actual card-carrying Communist ("This is a membership card in a subversive Communist-front organization—he must be a Red!").

    ReplyDelete
  46. BigHank538:28 AM

    Oh, are the baddies North Koreans? I couldn't be arsed to find out, after all the shitheaded technical inaccuracies in the trailer. (#1: The top of the Washington Monument getting sliced off by the wing of an airplane. Try breaking a cinderblock with an empty beer can and get back to me, sport.)

    ReplyDelete
  47. fraser8:31 AM

    Actually, with the breakaway little postage-stamp countries in the Balkans now, it doesn't seem that dated. There was never any sign Latveria was particularly a Soviet breakaway state.

    ReplyDelete
  48. BigHank538:31 AM

    Eh, why pity him? He should get what he wants, in my opinion. The only issue is that he isn't satisfied with the company of consenting adults*, and he wants everyone to accompany him.


    *True, they're probably hard to find. But that's your problem, Mr. Judge.

    ReplyDelete
  49. BigHank538:36 AM

    I'm trying to come up with a visual metaphor for a defined benefit pension plan, and the only ones I can think of are kindly grandmothers and fairy godmothers. Now, I'm certain there's an audience that wants to see the Hulk smash the crap out of either (or both) of those, but I have my doubts as to the size of that audience....

    ReplyDelete
  50. BigHank538:42 AM

    So Acculturated seems to be on the verge of becoming self-refuting.


    Acculturated was self-refuting from the moment they came up with the idea. Why is popular culture popular? It's right there in the adjective, nitwit: unpopular stuff doesn't become part of the culture, does it? Christ, these people have such huge blind spots it's amazing they don't need seeing-eye dogs.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Derelict8:52 AM

    There's ignorance, and then there's aggressive ignorance. It is the latter that Fox both produces and thrives on. Aggressive ignorance produces self-propelling fallacies--sort of a perpetual-motion machine of stupid. For Fox and its viewers, it's a limitless source of energy.

    ReplyDelete
  52. redoubt8:54 AM

    Red Ghost and his cosmic-powered monkeys (great band name)
    Somebody should make this happen, so they can open for the B-52s.

    ReplyDelete
  53. redoubt9:04 AM

    For values of "communism" read "NKVD shooting you in the neck in Lubyanka Prison".

    ReplyDelete
  54. Doghouse Riley9:22 AM

    So the Kim du Toit career arc is still considered viable?

    ReplyDelete
  55. but I have my doubts as to the size of that audience....

    Oh, come on. Thanks to P90X, Paul Ryan has bulked up significantly. And since we're now on the subject of assholes, Pete Peterson is positively titanic.

    ReplyDelete
  56. BigHank5310:00 AM

    "Family" focus-groups a lot better than "patriarchal kleptocracy with theocratic overtones", the form of government that Judge seems to be fondest of. Also, and not incidentally, it's easier to spell.

    ReplyDelete
  57. Jay B.10:06 AM

    "Listen, comrade, brother, we are equals here, workers should control the means of production, it is after all..."

    "Shut up, yegg, IT'S CLOBBERING TIME!"



    A snippet from Fantastic Four: The Pinkerton's Ace in the Hole.

    ReplyDelete
  58. This. This.This. Will get this comment taken out for a spin in the patriarchal kleptocracy's rambler and then to a lovely dinner with theocratic overtones.

    ReplyDelete
  59. BDSM is a hell of a thing to waste.

    ReplyDelete
  60. Jay B.10:14 AM

    I always thought he was a metaphor for greed. THINK ABOUT IT.

    ReplyDelete
  61. Jay B.10:19 AM

    Imagine if it was Von Doom and Van Jones teaming up, OMG!!! I know, Van Halen, Von Doom and Van Jones. And then Mr. Fantastic is all "Nuh-huh, not here, you rocking freaks." The Triple V Alliance? YES. And the Human Torch gets almost swayed by Eddie's sweet licks and Van Jones sensible moderate socialism, but then DOOM brings the pain. FUCK!! It can't miss.

    ReplyDelete
  62. Yeah, it really is baffling. He could have said Cucumbers vs. Bathroom design and it would make more sense,

    ReplyDelete
  63. XeckyGilchrist11:20 AM

    I am afraid to look at its Box Office.

    Stay away from microscopes and you'll be fine.

    ReplyDelete
  64. calling all toasters12:01 PM

    This guy is brilliant: the Fantastic Four is about families, not how cool it is to have superpowers. For his next trick, he will discover that Spiderman is about teenage anxiety. If he ever figures out that most Spielberg movies are about reuniting families he'll be the smartest conservative ever.

    ReplyDelete
  65. Plus, Cucumbers vs. Bathroom Design would actually have the benefit of being interesting. In fact, I'm pretty certain "Cucumbers vs. Bathroom Design" is an indie band beloved by hipsters.

    ReplyDelete
  66. As long as we're talking about the Red Dawn remake, this must be read by all.

    ReplyDelete
  67. tigrismus12:37 PM

    The problem with focusing on communism is that most people haven't felt threatened by it for a couple decades now. Hell, folks are more afraid of bed bugs than they are commies.

    ReplyDelete
  68. catclub12:57 PM

    Oranges and graphic design. They might be giants

    ReplyDelete
  69. Jay B.12:57 PM

    But only their first album "Limping Ponies", after that they got too frivolous.

    ReplyDelete
  70. BigHank5312:58 PM

    That is worth reading.

    ReplyDelete
  71. catclub12:59 PM

    Where do the Von Trapp's fit in?

    ReplyDelete
  72. aimai1:04 PM

    Yup. Quite good.

    ReplyDelete
  73. Jay B.1:35 PM

    The choir

    ReplyDelete
  74. Scott C.1:39 PM

    Fortunately, at the end Van Helsing shows up and lays waste to the commies with that Sacred Wafer he wields by Indulgence from the Bishop of Amsterdam -- exactly the same way John Paul II won the Cold War.

    ReplyDelete
  75. XeckyGilchrist2:12 PM

    To understand this kind of thing you really have to strap on the chest waders and venture into the wingnut conceptual cesspool, where all terms denoting or connoting things that are "good" can be used interchangeably ("democracy", "family", "freedom", etc.) and likewise all those for things that are "bad" ("terrorism", "communism", "fascism", etc.)

    One of my favorite contrasts of the sort was after Fahrenheit 9/11 came out, there was some movie touted by cons as the antidote or some such; it was one of those epic-imagery shows with georgeous flyovers of the Grand Canyon and other wonderful American scenery - AFAIK, no political message at all and, if I remember right, not even any words. How that was the Anti-Fahrenheit 9/11 made no sense at all unless you saw it in the wingnut frame i.e. "Fahrenheit 9/11 says America is bad, this movie says America is good."

    ReplyDelete
  76. You know what I'm afraid of? Communist bedbugs.

    ReplyDelete
  77. tigrismus2:36 PM

    БEДБUГS: They'll wait in line for hours to bite you! Talk about a gutsy directorial move.

    ReplyDelete
  78. Uatu the Watcher3:22 PM

    There are many worlds beyond your own. On one it has come to pass ...

    ReplyDelete
  79. This is the biting line? I thought I was getting toilet paper!

    ReplyDelete
  80. This is the only explanation that even remotely makes sense to me...which makes me so sad.



    I prefer families to Nazi prison camps, however. Just putting that out there.

    ReplyDelete
  81. XeckyGilchrist3:42 PM

    Relieved to hear it.

    (Looks like I got the film wrong - it's more pointedly USAian than I thought, but still all that overtly political, from the sound of it. http://community.seattletimes.nwsource.com/archive/?date=20040702&slug=heart02 )

    ReplyDelete
  82. XeckyGilchrist3:49 PM

    Of course, this only reinforces, hones, and strengthens my point, aside from being central to it.

    ReplyDelete
  83. tinheart4:36 PM

    Don't you know, comrade, that you stand in line and take whatever it is that they have in stock? Sometimes it's toilet paper, sometimes it's bedbugs. Sometimes it's vodka, sometimes it's VD. За тебя!

    ReplyDelete
  84. BigHank534:49 PM

    My uncle Vlad still gets morose about the time he mistakenly bought 6,000 drunken syphilitic bedbugs. But he only had to stand in one line!

    ReplyDelete
  85. tigrismus5:05 PM

    Not to be missed wrestling match?

    ReplyDelete
  86. Halloween_Jack5:40 PM

    NONE MORE METAL THAN DOOM.

    ReplyDelete
  87. AGoodQuestion6:06 PM

    I don't see why I shouldn't kick back with some lemon cookies and a glass of Knob Creek and just watch the explosion.
    Wear goggles.

    ReplyDelete
  88. AGoodQuestion6:10 PM

    As long as we're praising Milligan, if you can find trades of the old Shade the Changing Man series from Vertigo, jump on them. X-Statix is a lot of fun too.

    ReplyDelete
  89. Well, it's always a bummer when you think you're standing in line to get into a hot pub but you end up at CPAC.

    ReplyDelete
  90. whetstone7:11 PM

    That sounds kind of boring, but I would definitely watch a remake of Fail-Safe where the U.S. accidentally launches a nuclear family against Moscow.

    ReplyDelete
  91. Guh. So this film celebrating America (which I have no problem with, btw...sounds like a perfectly lovely film to me) is somehow the conservative equivalent to Michael Moore's film...even though the two films have nothing to do with one another? I'm not confused...I'm just...these people are weird.

    ReplyDelete
  92. M. Krebs8:35 PM

    I'm kinda baffled by "Don't even change, fella." Is that a typo?

    ReplyDelete
  93. Tudor Jennings9:09 PM

    I thought it was about the Communist Menace and fear of the Atomic Bomb. Gamma Rays, innit.
    Although I now expect Judge to jump on the whole "green monster" eco-terrorism thing. But then, somebody on the interwebs has probably already done that. And if they haven't......First. :P

    ReplyDelete
  94. Tudor Jennings9:10 PM

    When's he going to write an article about why Atlas Shrugged was such a pile of crap because it didn't concentrate on the cuddly family-first subplot?

    ReplyDelete
  95. Tudor Jennings9:14 PM

    The Torch is a mass of incandescent gas....

    ReplyDelete
  96. Tudor Jennings9:16 PM

    Now now, surely that's because he has Mother Issues.
    The dirty no good commie weirdo...

    ReplyDelete
  97. M. Krebs10:30 PM

    Patriarchal Kleptocracy drives a Rambler? I'm thinking Lincoln Town Car.

    ReplyDelete
  98. bjkeefe3:09 AM

    I think there's just a little glob of something on your screen, under the R.

    Blame Anal!

    Or Ariel. One of those.

    ReplyDelete
  99. edroso9:47 AM

    Yes it is -- or rather was, as I have "memory-holed" my typo by replacing the "n" with an "r" without so much as a correction/apology to Breitbart.com. That's my MSM lie for the day!

    ReplyDelete
  100. Comic book movies need more political propaganda in them. Especially now that Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy is complete.


    What can the Amazing Spiderman tell us about the wisdom of capital gains tax cuts?

    ReplyDelete